Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Attention Blade of the Immortal Fans!

I'm trying to figure out how many poses from this year's Rising Stars of Manga finalist Samurai Zombie were ripped off from Blade of the Immortal. In the first three volumes of BoTI I found this one, this one, and this one.

...what the heck. I wouldn't do this with a legitimate entry, but here's a zip file of the contest entry in question, for ease of comparison:

Samurai Zombie Dot Zip

The Samurai Zombie figures I'm talking about are on the fourth page bottom right, fifth page top left, and eighth page bottom right. This is using the page numbers on the zip file, where two pages = one page, because the original pages aren't numbered and I can't be bothered to count them. It's really obvious which poses I mean, anyway.

EDIT For the record, since this post is being passed around: I'm not the one who first pointed out the similarities between Samurai Zombie and Blade of the Immortal. That was telophase. She talks about it in her review of this year's Rising Stars of Manga finalists here (first part of post here).

EDIT 2: This panel comparison wins. Recreates the entire last page of Samurai Zombie from Blade of the Immortal panels, among other things (comparison is madame_manga's).


For the last few days I've been reading_genji. XD about time, I've only been in that community since December! I probably won't be as detailed after chapter 11 (the last chapter I read over the summer in a different translation) since it's a total pain in the neck, but here's my summary/commentary for the first four chapters of The Tale of Genji:


Or just check the main community page, they'll be the first four entries from the top. Generally I'm not trying to be entertaining or deep, just thorough, in that the entries are what I honestly think (plus background information so that people who haven't read the book will be able to follow along).

A few general translation notes:
• Seidensticker translation is so much better than Waley, omg. The biggest difference is that one is written in involved Victorian English and has sentences as long as my arm, while the other is written in clear modern English. It might be that Waley's version is closer to the style of the original, which I hear is very involved, but Seidensticker's reads more easily, which is a relief.
• Very few footnotes in Seidensticker. I thought I'd be lost without Waley's notes naming unnamed characters, but it is actually easier to read without them. It figures: I've always been terrible with names, much better with descriptions and relationships.
• So far I don't miss the constant general Heien cultural notes either, but we'll see how I feel about that once I get to the chapters I haven't read yet. XD. I'll probably be okay, because this isn't my first work of Heien-era literature, but if I get stuck on anything I'll ask about it here? Where probably dozens of people will know more about this stuff than I do, and might be willing to explain it to me XD.


Mar. 10th, 2006 08:40 pm (UTC)
REPOST, grammar
telophase pointed it out in her RSoM reviews (here and here), although I like to think I would have noticed anyway. According to her, at least 25% of the poses are copied. She also says using poses in other manga as a partial reference is one thing; copying the most memorable poses from Blade of the Immortal wholesale and then writing a manga called Samurai Zombie is just dumb. It's a miracle the Tokyopop editors didn't catch on.

Yeah! Like a treasure hunt! (Although now I wonder if I shouldn't have made this its own post, if you're going to link it... ah well, hindsight.)
Mar. 10th, 2006 09:35 pm (UTC)
Re: REPOST, grammar
... Is anyone reporting this/going to report it?

I mean, just wonderin'. (Er, I'd actually look at the other posts you've linked, but that'd take EFFORT ok!!)
Mar. 10th, 2006 09:49 pm (UTC)
this not being able to reply by email this is BLOODY ANNOYING
At least one person who works for Tokyopop (greenapple2004) reads telophase's journal, so I think it's safe to say they know about it. I might email them with a side-by-side panel comparison after I get clearer idea of exactly how many of the poses in that comic are from Blade of the Immortal.
Mar. 10th, 2006 10:53 pm (UTC)
Re: REPOST, grammar
Not only is there one Tpop employee who's open about it who's friended my journal, there's another one who is close-mouthed about it who's friended, and at least two others pop in periodically. They know.
Mar. 10th, 2006 09:48 pm (UTC)
Re: REPOST, grammar
Damn, how dumb can the editors of Tpop be?

BTW, a book you might want to read for help on Heian period details is World of the Shining Prince.
Mar. 11th, 2006 01:33 am (UTC)
Re: REPOST, grammar
Oh - the 25% number was me pulling a stat out of my ass, not me counting them carefully, BTW. :D

Latest Month

November 2010



This journal is 90% public. I friend back anything that moves (meaning anything that is not a blank journal), but it helps if you let me know that you've added me. Thanks!
Powered by LiveJournal.com